Best Charcoal Grill

The Char-Broil American Gourmet Charcoal Grill scored high marks in all areas and is our top pick. This convenient grill provides 568 square inches of total cooking space on its 30″ diameter grilling surface. The bowl of the grill is porcelain-enameled and has a glass-reinforced nylon handles. The aluminum, rust-resistant ash catcher makes removing and dumping ashes and aluminized-steel one touch cleaning system that makes clean up easy. The cooking grate is hinged so you can add charcoal during cooking if necessary. There is a 10 year warranty on this product.

Charcoal Grill Review
13 mins to read
64 products considered
18 products reviewed
44 hours reviewing

1. Char-Broil

Best Overall Charcoal Grill

5/5 Product Rating
You will have more than enough room to cook plenty of food for large groups with 840 square inches if total cooking surface. There is 272 square inches of secondary cooking on a chrome-plated swing away.

On the primary cooking area which features cast iron grates, there is 568 square inches. There’s plenty of space to cook up to 20 hamburgers at once so cooking for a crowd is easy and no one has to wait.

The multiple dampers and steel fire grate that has an adjustable height can control the heat and smoke that allows the griller to have complete control over the sear their foods get. There is a temperature gauge right in the hood of the grill that allows the griller to monitor the heat that the food is cooking at so nothing burns.

The front shelf is full length and there are three convenient hooks for grilling tools as well so they are always within reach. The two folding shelves give plenty of space t keep tools, ingredients and accessories close by while you are cooking. The spring handle is cool to the touch even while grilling and the wheels make for easy mobility.

Sarah Lytle

2. Char-Griller

Best Overall Charcoal Grill – Runner Up

4.8/5 Product Rating
Char-Griller Pro Deluxe has a whopping 580 square inches of primary cooking space and 270 square inches of warming racks.

The cast iron cooking surface has four lift-able sections that allow the user to reach the coals easily. With adjustable grates and an easy to dump ash pan, grillers will enjoy every moment of cooking out.

The wood side shelf with utensil hooks and a wire condiment basket round out the great features this charcoal grill has.

The cart of this charcoal grill is made of tubular steel and the body of the grill is made of heavy duty steel as well, making it long lasting and durable. The large 8” wheels make it easy to move wherever you need to use it.

The large wire shelf on the bottom is good for storing charcoal and other things that you need while grilling. It is super easy to assemble and clean up as well. The heat gauge helps time your cooking so your food comes out perfectly. It is a great grill to have for anyone who enjoys charcoal grilling. Makes a terrific gift too.

Sarah Lytle

3. Weber

Best Budget Charcoal Grill

4.5/5 Product Rating
Grilling enthusiasts get traditional style and easy clean up with the Weber 741001 Original Kettle 22” Charcoal Grill.

It has 363 square inches of total cooking space along with a porcelain-enameled bowl and lid that has glass-reinforced nylon handles and an aluminum ash catcher and aluminized-steel One-Touch cleaning system.

Users will have plenty of cooking space for entertaining your friends and family. The three pronged cleaning system gets rid of the ashes quickly by sweeping them into the removable, ash catcher that is rust resistant.

The hinged, stainless steel cooking grate allows users to add more charcoal even while cooking. The two all-weather wheels make moving it from one place to another very easy.

The vent allows the griller to control the temperature inside. The porcelain enamel that has been baked on at 1500 degrees F ensures that the grill can withstand many hours of cooking.

It is burn-through resistant as well. The durability of this grill will provide tons of opportunity for cookouts and comes with a 10 year warranty too.

Sarah Lytle

Charcoal Grill Comparison









PK Grills

(sq in)
840 850 363 297 250 850 240 153 300 406
30 30 22 18 16 29 18 14 16 18
2 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 5


Charcoal Grill Buying Guide

Best Charcoal Grill

What is a Charcoal Grill?

Charcoal Grill1A charcoal grill works by having charcoal loaded into the bowl just under the grate. Charcoal is the fuel source for a charcoal grill. When the charcoal is burned, it will turn into embers that radiate heat up toward the top vent. The temperature is controlled by adjusting the vents to allow more or less oxygen into the charcoal grill.

When you decide you want to get a charcoal grill, you need to understand the type of cooking you will be doing with it. There’s a difference between cooking hot dogs or burgers and slow cooking ribs. Think about how you will be using your grill and think about the questions below before you start your search.

Considerations before Purchase

  • What size meals will are you cooking? – If you will be cooking for a large family or you have a lot of friends that come over on a regular basis, you will want a larger charcoal grill than you would need if you were just cooking for a couple of people. You want to be sure that there is enough room to cook as much as possible at one time so people don’t have to eat in shifts whenever you have a cookout.
  • Can I Control the Temperature Easily? – Make sure that the charcoal grill you are considering has top and bottom vents. These vents will help you control the temperature your food is cooked at. Some grills will have the ability to adjust the placement of the charcoal, raising or lowering it away from the grate.
  • Easy to Clean – If the charcoal grill is super hard to clean, you’re not going to want to use it. Look for an easy to clean mechanism. Whether it’s an ash tool or ash bins underneath with a removal method, you want to find a grill that offers simple removal of the ashes and easy cleaning.

Why Cook with a Charcoal Grill?

There are many reasons people love using a charcoal grill over a gas grill. We have outlined the most popular reasons below.

  1. Flavor of the Food – Charcoal grilled foods typically have a smokier, richer flavor than foods cooked on a gas grill. Lump charcoal gives off stronger smoke aromas and flavors that get into the food.
  2. Easy to Move Around – Most charcoal grills have wheels that make them easy to move around if needed. They are also nit very heavy so moving from one place to another or even taking to the park is relatively easy.
  3. Temperature Range – You can increase the cooking temperature by adjusting the air vents on the top and/or bottom of the grill. You can put a rack of ribs on the grill at 225 degrees and cook it slowly over four hours or cook a pizza at 500 degrees for only 20 minutes. The range is very versatile.
  4. Easy to Maintain – The mechanisms used for grills makes them easy to maintain. There is typically a grill grate, the compartment where the charcoal goes, and the chamber below that where the ashes are deposited to be cleaned out later. You can remove the ashes when completely cool with a shop vacuum, or by hand.
  5. Traditional Cooking – Many people love old school grilling which does not involve using a gas grill. Charcoal grills provide all the flavor along with the nostalgia that comes with old fashioned charcoal grilling.

What to Look for in a Charcoal Grill

  • A good cooking system – a well designed charcoal grill has sturdy, heavy-duty steel or cast iron cooking grates and a charcoal grate to put the charcoal on. There should also be a lid with vents. Look for an efficient ash removal system as well.
  • Charcoal Grill2

  • Construction – Check reviews to see what customers have to say about the sturdiness of the grill you are considering. Does it feel flimsy to the customers that have purchased it? Are there complaints about the sturdiness? Make sure that the reviews are favorable for sturdiness and strong.
  • Easy Assembly – Easy to assemble is a big priority when it comes to a good quality charcoal grill. You don’t want to have to fight with putting together your grill so look for designs that state they are easy to put together.
  • Service/Warranties – You want to have great customer service from the manufacturer that you purchase your charcoal grill from. In the event you need them for something, knowing that customer service is important to them is a relief to know. Look for good warranties as well. When a company has a good warranty backing up their products, you know they stand behind their quality.

Types of Charcoal Grills

There are a few different types of charcoal grills on the market. Some have heat controls, are round, rectangular or square, some have wheels and some had lids. We have listed several of the types of charcoal grills below so you can see which ones appeal to you.

  • Ceramic – This is the most effective and flexible type of charcoal grill available. The ceramic chamber retains heat and moisture better than any other type of charcoal grill. They can be used for grilling, smoking and even baking pizza right on the grill. Thanks to the heat retention, you can cook things on a ceramic grill that you may not be able to on others. Some ceramic charcoal grills can produce temperatures of up to 750 degrees.
  • Barrel – Barrel charcoal grills look like a steel barrel cut in half and stuck on its side. The hinges are on the top half that forms a lid and the bottom half is where the charcoal goes. The vents that control temperature are in the top and bottom of the barrel. Barrel charcoal grills have a chimney to control the smoke escaping that is attached to the lid.
  • Kettle – The kettle charcoal grill has a lid, cooking grid, charcoal grid, lower chamber, venting system and legs too. Some Kettle charcoal grills have ash catcher pans and wheels for easy mobility. The bottom part of the grill that holds the charcoal is shaped like a kettle, giving this popular grill its name. The kettle design distributes heat evenly, producing well cooked food.

Types of Charcoal

There are two types of charcoal that is used to cook in a charcoal grill: Lump charcoal and charcoal briquettes. Each one has their advantages.

Lump Charcoal – Lump charcoal is in its natural form and is easy to light. It produces less ash than regular briquettes do and provides a natural smoke flavor that creates delicious foods. Lump charcoal responds well to oxygen which makes it much easier to control temperature while cooking. It has no fillers or chemicals that help it light up or burn longer. It is a cleaner option than other charcoal.

Charcoal Briquettes – Some people have referred to charcoal briquettes as the fast food of charcoal because it lights easy and has a lot of uniformity in size and the length of time it will burn. There are chemicals involved in the creation of charcoal briquettes that can make it hazardous to your health when it first starts burning so do you best not to breathe it in or put the food on the grill until you see ash on top of the briquettes.

Charcoal Grill Features

The features listed below are some of the most common features a charcoal grill can have. They add convenience and ease to your grilling experience.

  • Lights – Some grills have attached grill lights that make cooking in the dark or low light conditions much easier. If your grill doesn’t have one, they can be purchased separately. You will love having a grill light and will wish you have gotten one sooner.
  • Cast Iron Cooking Grates – Cast iron is heavy duty, provides a great sear on your food and is super easy to clean. They can rust so you will need to be sure they don’t get wet.
  • V- Racks – These racks are used to hold racks of ribs upright. You can also flip the rack upside down and to hold the roast or poultry.
  • Wheels – Wheels are on most charcoal grills unless they are meant to be stationary. The wheels allow the grill to be moved from one place to the next much easier.

Common Charcoal Grill Accessories

Charcoal Grill3There are many accessories that you can purchase that upgrade the grill’s performance and make the whole grilling experience even better. None of them are mandatory, but they will make your grilling experience much better.

  • Starters
  • Thermometers
  • Covers
  • Meat claws
  • Basting Brushes
  • Magnetic Grill Lights
  • Sauce Mops
  • Grill Rings


There are many different types of charcoal grills that you can choose from. Knowing a little bit about charcoal grills can help you choose the right model for your grilling needs. This buyer’s guide has provided the information you need to sort through the different models and types of charcoal grills on the market and will make choosing one much easier.

With grilling being so popular, having a great charcoal grill that has plenty of room to cook for your friends and family can transform your warm weather days and nights into something truly enjoyable.


  1. Weber –
  2. Char Griller –
  3. Char Broil –

Sarah Lytle

Sarah's passion for cooking and eating healthy is what drives her to research and educate others. Sarah is our expert researcher who manages the Home and Kitchen category. When she's not writing you'll find her listening to Paleo Diet podcasts and educating people on how to live and eat primally.

Recent Posts